WeatherTech vs. Husky Liners vs. Maxliner: 3 Top Custom Fit Floor Mats Compared

About the Author

@mikeptaylor

Mike is a husband and father of 2 who studies the art of never paying full price for anything.

WeatherTech vs. Husky Liners vs. Maxliner: 3 Top Custom Fit Floor Mats Compared

Looking for quality floor mats but not sure which ones to pick?

It might sound absurd to some people, but floor mats are a big investment in your vehicle.

Think about it: Have you ever had a car or truck that didn’t have floor mats?

Give it 6 months to a year and the carpet is all but ruined. You can try to get it shampooed, but we all know that only works so many times (not to mention it’s extremely frustrating).

Whether you’re looking to protect your vehicle’s carpet from your kids, snowmageddon, or just muddy shoes, you can’t go wrong spending the extra money for custom molded floor mats.

Now, because custom fit floor mats aren’t exactly cheap, getting the rundown on the best brands in the market is very necessary.

Three brands rise above the rest as the best options for custom-fit floor mats: WeatherTech, Husky Liners, and Maxliner. The problem is trying to pick between these three.

All three have great reputations, quality products, and tons of happy customers.

So if you’ve narrowed it down to WeatherTech, Husky, and Maxliner, but just can’t find enough evidence to make a decision, you’re in luck.

Here’s what you need to know about the best custom fit floor mats so you can actually pull the trigger and start protecting your vehicle’s carpet. (Because they’re getting dirtier as you read!)

Note: Much of the information used to compare these brands was found by going to AutoAnything.com and using a demo vehicle for pricing: a 2012 Chevrolet Silverado. Any reference to pricing or reviews is referring to data found on AutoAnything.com for that particular vehicle type.

WeatherTech Extreme-Duty DigitalFit Floor Liners

If you’ve been looking around at custom molded floor mats, you’ve probably heard the most about WeatherTech. They have a strong brand, and make a quality product.

One thing you’ll hear many WeatherTech owners talk about is how durable the material WeatherTech mats are made from. WeatherTech mats are thick and have more of a “rubbery” feel as opposed to plastic.

Their anchoring system tends to keep them in place a little better than other mats that have the cleats on the back to keep them in place instead.

Here’s a quick rundown of the info you’ll find on AutoAnything for this WeatherTech product:

  • Price: $247.90 (you can pay less than that by using WeatherTech promos on Dealspotr)

  • Colors: Black, Grey, Tan

  • Laser measured

  • Warranty: 3 year

  • Percent of reviews that are 4 or 5 stars: 95%

  • Complaints from reviewers: Improper fit/poor fit (many of the 1-star reviews were actually great reviews, the reviewer just selected the wrong number of stars)

Husky Liners WeatherBeater Floor Liners

Husky is another very well-known brand in the custom floor mat space. Their mats are very durable and come with a lifetime warranty. They’re typically a little cheaper than WeatherTech mats, but they tend to have great reviews.

Their mat is made with a material that has been described by reviewers as being a little more “slick” and less thick, but they’re also supposedly easier to remove and clean.

Husky floor mats come with raised “nibs” (I call them cleats) on the back that are like little mini-spikes. These help keep the mat in place so they don’t move around.

As is expected, there are negative reviewers, but those should be taken with a grain of salt. Sometimes people will post a negative review when they just don’t understand the product or what they bought in the first place.

Here’s a quick rundown of the info you’ll find on AutoAnything for this Husky Liners product:

  • Price: $179.95 (you can pay less than that by using Husky Liners promos on Dealspotr)

  • Colors: Black, Grey, Tan

  • Laser measured

  • Warranty: Lifetime

  • Percent of reviews that are 4 or 5 stars: 96%

  • Complaints from reviewers: “Flimsy” material - plastic, poor fit (again, many of the 1-star reviews were actually great reviews)

Maxliner Maxfloormats

Maxliner provides a quality alternative to their two more expensive competitors, but they also offer a lifetime warranty to stand behind their product.

If you see negative reviews for this product, they’ll likely focus on poor fit and flimsy/cheap material (notice a theme?). But considering the price difference, you wouldn’t expect them to be made of top-notch material or fit flawlessly. That’s why they’re cheaper.

Ask yourself this: Do you need your carpet protected, or do you want perfection?

That’s not to say Maxliner provides a sub-par product by any means. It’s just the cheapest option among the three, so setting your expectations appropriately will do you a lot of good, and could save yourself some disappointment if they’re not sheer perfection when they get to your house.

Here’s a quick rundown of the info you’ll find on AutoAnything for this Maxliner product:

  • Price: $152.98 (you can pay less than that by using Maxliner promos on Dealspotr)

  • Colors: Black, Grey, Tan

  • Computerized custom fit

  • Warranty: Lifetime

  • Percent of reviews that are 4 or 5 stars: 87%

  • Complaints from reviewers: Poor fit, plastic-like material

Conclusion

Although WeatherTech mats are more expensive, customers seem to really stand behind their product. They describe it as sturdy and thick (but not too stiff), with plenty of grip so your feet don’t slip when wet.

The number one complaint on AutoAnything was that the mats didn’t fit properly, but a certain amount of that is probably to be expected with all the many different makes and models of vehicles. I mean, hey, I’d say having a few mats that wiggle a little isn’t the worst thing you can say about a company.

Having said that, Husky is a VERY worthy competitor. If you want to save a little money but still get a quality product, Husky might be the way to go. Just expect a bit more “rigid” and slick material.

Husky also has the sharp cleat-like spikes on the back to keep them in place as opposed to the anchor system WeatherTech mats use. Just remember, they have a lifetime warranty and a very similar amount of positive reviews as WeatherTech, so obviously they’re doing something right.

Lastly, if you’re a little more budget-conscious but still want a good set of custom-fit mats, Maxliner might be just the brand to fit the bill. Sure, some negative reviewers have said the material doesn’t seem top-notch and they sometimes don’t fit perfectly, but that happens even with the more expensive brands. With Maxliner’s lifetime warranty and low(er) price point, it might be just what you need to get the job done.

Get each week's best deals from Dealspotr in your inbox

This guide was published on September 19, 2016, and last modified on September 19, 2016.
Stores related to this article: WeatherTech, Max Liner, Husky Liners

Enjoy this guide? Spread good knowledge.